Hello! You may have arrived here via Google, or a link on someone else’s site.

Unfortunately I don’t blog much anymore so I’ve removed these pages from the main navigation. You’re welcome to read all you like, though. Use the search box below to look through posts, or dig through the archives here. You can also check out my Tumblr blog instead: http://luclatulippe.tumblr.com/.

Aug 23 2007

Small business accounting

(34) Comments 
Despite Googling my butt off in my spare hours over the past several months, I remain incapable of finding a halfway decent business accounting app. My criteria for this mythical beast are, I think, extremely basic. It should:


- be able to create and send invoices
- be able to handle multiple currencies and taxes
- be able to track business expenses (bonus option: time-tracking)
- (EDIT!) be able to generate annual/monthly reports
- be intuitive and extremely simple to learn
- allow me to include my terms either as a text or PDF attachment
- be affordable
- preferably be a web app

  • if YES: it should work in ANY browser

  • if NO: it should have a fully supported Mac version



Sounds simple? Evidently, it would seem I am overly demanding. This particular combo of features is insanely difficult to find.

Once upon a time...

In 2002, I forked over the $600 for a copy of QuickBooks' Accounts for Mac. A few months later, following a VERY steep learning curve thanks to its extremely poorly designed interface and an utterly useless Help File, QuickBooks ceased production and support of QAFM. In addition, the "new" version of this app, QuickBooks Pro for Mac, is completely unable to import the data from the old version. Nice. At least at $200 it's cheaper. But with so little support for Macs, and the crappy reputation QuickBooks has in general, I am not interested in "upgrading." Besides, at any moment it may end up just killing it on me again. No thanks.


So, what has searching yielded? The following...

Software

MYOB ($99 - $299)
Not inspiring confidence in me when you have no Canadian website on your splash page. Malaysia, Ireland, Singapore: Yes. But no Canada. Also, their site sucks. Hey MYOB dummies: You can't do a word search on web pages where all the data on them resides in ONE GIANT JPG file! Sigh. I'm also not sure I want to buy into another "big company's" software, when I know their support for Mac-users is not a big focus.

Billings
This thing presents too much of a learning curve. I spent half a day with it and it did nothing but vex me. It's not designed intuitively. Nothing is where you think it might be, nor works the way you think it should. And I'm nerdy enough to feel comfortable figuring my way through new apps.

They also chose to reinvent basic accounting language which is already imprinted into our brains: instead of "Invoices" they're called "Working Slips." Instead of "Quotes" they're called "Estimate Slips." And what's a "Slip Blueprint?" I have no idea, I gave up after getting dizzy from constantly zipping back and forth between the app itself and its own help file. And I still can't locate how the hell to input EXPENSES into this thing either, despite that it claims it does have that feature. The interface seems to over-complicate what I think should be a simple process. And it comes with a 32-page PDF "quick start" guide to boot. Yeah. No.

It does, however, have a very smart little time-tracking clock which does behave intuitively and permanently resides in your Mac's menu bar for quick access. But that's hardly enough to make me cough up payment, even if it only costs CDN$74. I really wanted to like this one. I may play with it again and see how it goes, but I doubt it.

Invoice
Another boringly named app. It's not bad, only costs US$45, it's very Mac-like, but it's missing little things like being able to drag-and-drop from my Address Book, email a copy of an invoice directly from within the app (I know, I can just as easily use OS X's built-in "Print > Print as PDF", whatever), and what else? Umm.. oh yes: BEING ABLE TO TRACK EXPENSES. Jeebus... Why is this so hard?

MoneyWorks Gold (CDN$178 - CDN$2371)
Cognito's CDN$708 MoneyWorks Gold is their cheapest product that seems to come very close to meeting my needs. It's what my local Mac store has used for several years, and they swear by it. It seems to have lots of support and shows no signs of going tits-up any time soon. While $700 seems like a lot, if you spread that over a period of 5 years, that's only $140/year, or about $12/month. At that price, it's not a bad contender. Plus, you get what you pay for. I've downloaded their demo version to test out, but haven't had time yet.

Web apps

Time59
Can't handle multiple currencies. The only expenses you can enter are those related DIRECTLY to an existing invoice. Only costs US$20/year though. Too limited for my needs.

Less Accounting
So far, this is the closest one with the most abilities. Missing: Multiple currencies. But it DOES allow you to input expenses. Great if you only do business in ONE currency, which few people do anymore.

Freshbooks
One of the more popular ones, but I don't know why. They actually limit the number of clients you can have, based on which plan you sign up for, and they don't even have a free, limited-use plan. It's been promising some "great new features soon" but until they add multiple currencies and the ability to add expenses, I'll wait. Once fancy feature: allows you to snail-mail invoices.

Blinksale
I used it for a while, but finally switched back to the free three-invoices-per-month-only plan. It does almost everything I need it to do: It allows for multiple currencies (you adjust it on a per-invoice basis, and it separates all your invoices accordingly, allowing you to view how much you've made in US$ vs. CDN$ vs. UK£ sales), lets you customize any tax(es) you need to add, it's very affordable, reliable, extremely easy to use, exports to .XLS, connects with your PayPal account. The only thing missing (you guessed it!): the ability to enter expenses! (Unless they're from an invoice sent to you via another Blinksale user). If it could do that, I'd use it exclusively. The developers seem to have disappeared lately.

Conclusions

The most glaring omission in all of these is their inability let you deal in multiple currencies, and track your business expenses. Let me repeat this, in web-yelling, with exclamation and question marks: THEY DON'T LET YOU TRACK YOUR BUSINESS EXPENSES?!?

This is one of the most basic things anyone needs from accounting software! Money in AND money out! How can you NOT let me track expenses? Do you assume my business only MAKES money, but never ever needs to spend it?

Where I'm at now

I can't believe you're still reading this. Ten points for you!

Where am I now? Back to square one! I'm still using my old Accounts for Mac software, at least until it eventually dies with some future OS X upgrade (probably when I end up getting Leopard... or Ocelot, or Tabby, or whatever it's called). At least I don't need to learn anything new, and have it sufficiently customized, but it's ugly, slow, and actually unpleasant to use.

In the meantime, I'll test out MoneyWorks Gold and report back. I hope it will impress.

Feedback? Ideas? Opinions? Recommendations? Comments? Please share.

———————————————————

Addendum

EDIT 1: Sept. 7, 2007
I just stumbled upon an app called Xero. Besides missing the ability to input in multiple currencies, it's just about perfect. (ps: It's restricted to New Zealanders for now. Drat!)



EDIT 2: Sept. 21, 2007
John Critz from Blinksale emailed and said they're currently working on adding the ability to input expenses AND time-tracking! He didn't give me a date, but hopes to roll these features out in the next two months. This pretty much sells me on Blinksale. Yay!


 

34 Comments

Picture of Cully Cully
2 years, 11 months ago

I haven’t tried it myself but there is a decent review of Cashboard at FreelanceSwitch

It seems at my cursory examination to have pretty much everything you are asking for.

Picture of Luc Luc
2 years, 11 months ago

Thanks for the tip about Cashboard. Unfortunately, I find it’s a lot like the rest of the Freshbooks/Blinksale-style knock-offs out there, and offers nothing new or innovative. And again: no way to input expenses. Frustrating.

For folks who want a direct link to Cashboard:
http://www.getcashboard.com/

Picture of Luc Luc
2 years, 11 months ago

ps: I’ll admit Cashboard has one nice feature: a Dashboard/Yahoo widget for time-tracking. That’s a step in the forward-thinking direction.

Picture of southendcb southendcb
2 years, 10 months ago

Don’t know how it handles all you need but check out MarketCircles ‘Billings 2.5’

It’s gorgeous. It surely works with time tracking and invoicing…not sure about the rest.

I don’t use it (yet) but I do use Daylite and it has a great OSX interface.

xo

http://www.billings2.com/

Picture of Luc Luc
2 years, 10 months ago

Yup, listed Billings above. I found it too clunky.

Picture of Lee Lee
2 years, 10 months ago

I have yet to find an accounting program for Mac since MYOB…so I bought ...augh….gurp…..a….pc. Then put Quick Book Pro on it.

Picture of chris hope chris hope
2 years, 10 months ago

Great article, spot on, there is not a perfect solution. I have been using Billings 2.5 the last 2 months and I am going to stick with it.  I totally agree with your review though.  Way to complicated and annoying than it should be.

Picture of J J
2 years, 10 months ago

I haven’t been in the freelance pool for several years now, but when I was, I used iBank & iBiz (formerly known as iWork) from IGG.  Not as powerful as QuickBooks but it had a great interface and was very stable.

http://www.iggsoftware.com

Picture of Dominique Dominique
2 years, 10 months ago

Hi, Luc,

For some free alternatives, you might want to try Turbocash or GNUCash.

For Mac, there’s also Grisbi.

I have a longer list at http://sme-in-a-box.org/BusinessApplications/Others The site is still a work-in-progress, though.

Picture of Jay Montgomery Jay Montgomery
2 years, 10 months ago

Hi Luc,

Great post/article. I’m on the Mac and for over 7 years I have used Filemaker Pro Contacts Estimates and Invoice templates that I have modified. I have an old version of Filemaker Pro 6 on my G5. It does not have some of the features you want but if you have Filemaker it’s practically free. You can save the multiple page invoices as a PDF directly from Filemaker.

Get them here off my website for free!
http://www.jaymontgomery.com/illustratorforms.html

Picture of Jason Rodrigues Jason Rodrigues
2 years, 10 months ago

I’m more tech than illustrator, but if you or someone you know can operate and maintain postgresql, Apache, and a CGI-Perl application,
http://www.ledgersmb.org/ is free and Open source.  It can email pdf invoices, manage multiple currencies, taxes, unlimited vendors or customers, automatic reoccurring billing, Inventory, warehousing, general ledger, etc.

Disclosure: I’m one of the developers on the project, and just stumbled upon this via drawn.ca ...

Picture of Richard Medek Richard Medek
2 years, 10 months ago

I’d like to chime in, in defense of Billings. While I admit some areas can be pretty frustrating (like customizing an invoice via it’s buggy and intimidating template editor), it’s been very easy for me to track time and expenses, as well create and track invoices.

The terminology of “slips” versus “invoice” is because “slips” are just items that you are tracking. Later, you select the slips you’d like to invoice for and make an invoice. One of the benefits to doing this separately is you can track time that isn’t invoiced to see if you’re losing money on a client.

To track expenses, you create a new slip and instead of choosing “timed” or “flat rate” or whatever, choose “expense.”

So, for a typical web client, I might have four timed slips—say, “graphic templates,” “html/css,” “CMS integration,” “beta testing”; an expenses slip, say “stock photos”; one slip not invoiced, say, “client meetings.”

I know one man’s meat is another’s poison and all, but I was surprised to hear the confusion between the slips and ability to track expenses since it was one of the biggest draws for me to Billings.

Picture of illosaurus illosaurus
2 years, 10 months ago

I second the iBiz recommendation. Not perfect but pretty good.

Picture of traylorillo traylorillo
2 years, 10 months ago

I’ve been using iBiz for about two years, now. It may not have everything you’re looking for but, like a couple other comments mention, it’s pretty good.

Picture of Luc Luc
2 years, 10 months ago

Thanks for sharing all your tips and suggestions folks! I’ll look into the other apps you mentioned and test them out to see how they feel

@ Jay Montgomery:
Thanks for those links to your business documents! These are wonderful. I considered looking into Filemaker, but wondered if it was more than I needed. I’ll check into it again though. (I also downloaded trial versions of Apple’s iWork programs, with the hopes of using their spreadsheets app; that’s how I used to track invoices/expenses years ago.)

@ Richard Medek:
I’m happy to hear you’ve mastered Billings! I just didn’t have the patience. As with anything though, there’s going to be a learning curve, like it or not. You’re right to have stuck with it until you had it figured out.

I added this EDIT at the bottom of the post, but in case anyone missed it, here it is again:
EDIT 2: John Critz from Blinksale emailed and said they’re currently working on adding the ability to input expenses AND time-tracking! He didn’t give me a date, but hopes to roll these features out in the next two months.

Picture of Bookkeeper Bookkeeper
2 years, 10 months ago

Thanks for this list…I’ve been searching for an alternative to QB for ages.  By the way, you might try a file-conversion service to turn your old file into a file that’s compatible with a newer version of QB. 

http://www.4luvofbiz.com/custom/FileTransfer.php

Picture of Steve Seeley Steve Seeley
2 years, 10 months ago

I had this same exact problem. Quickbooks accounts for mac was a joke. It turns out that this Canadian version was actually a rebranded version of MYOB, and had nothing to do with the *real* verson of Quickbooks.

I found that the best option was to install bootcamp on a new iMac, and run Quickbooks Pro on the PC. It works pretty well. Almost all bookeepers and accountants can use your files, and does everything on your list and a lot more.

Picture of tahuti tahuti
2 years, 10 months ago

Has anyone tried to install GnuCash on Mac?

Picture of Luc Luc
2 years, 10 months ago

Thanks Tahuti. For anyone interested, the URL to GnuCash is here: http://www.gnucash.org/

Actually, this looks like it has everything one might need. What confuses me and might keep me away, though, are notes like this:

For the Microsoft Windows operating system there is a self-installing setup program which includes all necessary additional libraries.

To install GnuCash on other platforms, users will need Gnome 2, guile, and slib. Neither the currently used swig nor the previously used g-wrap packages are needed anymore when compiling from tarball or when installing a binary. (my italics)

Um, I don’t know what the shit that means. I don’t have “Gnome 2” or “Guile” or “Slib” and I’m not sure I care to download them in order to download GnuCash.

...

(15 minutes and one download of GnuCash later):

I now have a GnuCash folder on my desktop that contains 45 items in it, and not one of those is the actual application. As I find is often the case with Open Source projects, this is a mess of stuff that only the most tech-savvy will venture into.

Sorry GnuCash. Zero stars for you, because you complicate the crap out of me.

Picture of Suzie Suzie
2 years, 10 months ago

I spent quite a bit of time trying to wade through many of the same apps you list above, and ended up with TimeNet from AppleSource.

I needed something really simple and easy to use, and found that while not specifically an accounting app, it offered all the features i wanted, without all of the extra bulk of the beefier programs.

It does a great job of keeping track of my clients, their projects and *gasp* expenses for each project. It offers customizable invoices that you can manage easily with different categories and archiving.

Each client has a profile where you can, among other things, change the currency.

it doesnt hook up to your bank account or write checks for you, but it does keep all of my work/time/money straight and with a pretty robust support forum monitored by the developer, any performance issues are pretty swiftly addressed by him or the community.

and it’s cheap. $45 or something.

Picture of Luc Luc
2 years, 10 months ago

Thanks Suzie! For anyone interested, here’s the URL for TimeNet: http://www.applesource.biz/software/timenet/

I’ll definitely check it out.

Picture of Frank Juval Frank Juval
2 years, 10 months ago

I thought I was on crack because I was the only one that hated every piece of accounting software out there.

It’s nice to know I’m not alone. So I’ll definitely keep posted to see if you find something that’s great. Not good, not “OK”, but great.

Also, it would be cool if the app had a way of letting one create a template with logo and artwork, in either full color or grayscale.

Picture of Matt Matt
2 years, 9 months ago

I’ve been using Studiometry (along with Accounted) from Oranged software for the past few months, and they’ve been working out very well for me.

http://www.oranged.net/

Picture of tdmc tdmc
2 years, 9 months ago

I’ve had the same problem and find it strange that no mac based writer has managed to put something together that is simple and intuitive. I don’t really want to learn accounting 101 to record my incomes and outgoings!
And many don’t offer GST/VAT recording - needed for us in Oz, and those in UK/NZ I think

Picture of Jessie Jessie
2 years, 9 months ago

I am also in search of an appropriate accounting software for Macs.  I have searched a long time to find almost no one talking about FileMaker Pro except for Apple. 

Maybe I will go to my Apple store and set up a Procare appnt to review FileMaker.  I like the features, but from what I hear,  the good news is you can customize everything.  The bad news is you must.  No click and use right now?
Ugh. Appreciate Jay’s biz docs as a place to start.

I will check out the recommendations for Oranged, Timeless and iBank, maybe a few others. 

I wonder if most people don’t want to spend so much on $ software.  I mean, that’s why we need it!  Also, Mac devlopers are right brained techies- that’s what I like about them generally.  So maybe money is just too left brained? 

Thanks for all the help everyone. I’ll let you know what I decide.

Picture of Luc Latulippe Luc Latulippe
2 years, 9 months ago

Thanks Jessie. I downloaded a 30-day free version of Filemaker, and have only played around with it briefly. It’s an amazing program, but it’s totally ungainly for my needs. Personally, I prefer something simple and straightforward. But I know that many people do use it and call it a favourite. I’m waiting (impatiently) for Blinksale to make those improvements they mentioned. (Drums fingers on table)

Picture of Sidney VanNess, Ph.D. Sidney VanNess, Ph.D.
2 years, 9 months ago

Luc,
On the 7th, we released AcuInvoice.  It does most of what you want and, unlike some of the others you have mentioned, we are in VERY active development at the moment and would more than welcome whatever feedback and feature requests you have.  We are releasing the first version of an API today, opened a user forum yesterday, and started to support domain mapping late last week (something that is, to my knowledge, unique in this space).  It takes constructive criticisms from people like you to improve these products, but as importantly the developers must listen.  We’re listening and responding quickly, so I’d encourage you to check us out.  If you like our service, great; if not, post some constructive criticisms and we’ll likely respond.  Thanks for a great post.

Picture of Sidney VanNess, Ph.D. Sidney VanNess, Ph.D.
2 years, 9 months ago

...and I forgot to mention that our service is entirely free at the moment.  That always helps :)

Picture of Luc Luc
2 years, 9 months ago

Thanks Sidney, I’ll take a look at it and see how it goes.

I’ll have to post a follow-up to this first article, maybe with some graphs and pie-charts or something.

Picture of Luc Latulippe Luc Latulippe
2 years, 9 months ago

Here’s another online invoicing app I just found:
http://www.simplyinvoices.com/

It’s bare-bones though, and doesn’t do anything more than the others mentioned above. Like a few of them, it also have support for Basecamp, if this turns your crank.

Picture of Sidney VanNess, Ph.D. Sidney VanNess, Ph.D.
2 years, 9 months ago

Luc,
One thing that I’d note about many of these applications (ours included) is a desire to keep the core functionality simple, but provide others (or the developers on behalf of the subscribers) the ability to extend the functionality of the application through the use of the API.  This allows the developers to really focus on the application’s core functionality and avoid the slippery slope that can be scope creep.  For example, one of our early adopters just yesterday asked us if we had plans to develop some sort of universal form generator that could interact with his AcuInvoice account.  He wanted to have a form that customers could fill out and have the order automatically passed to AcuInvoice; his reasoning was that this would save him time because his customers would be filling out all of the contact information, etc.  We told this customer that we had no plans to make this part of the core application, since most subscribers wouldn’t utilize this feature and it would just be another item sitting unused somewhere in the menu hierarchy.  However, we all agreed that this would be a good feature for a certain segment of users and have decided to put it on our development roadmap as something that could be implemented in conjunction with the API.  As a result, we’ll probably have a lightweight PHP script that subscribers can stick on their server and have it easily interact with our service.  The net result is extended functionality for the more advanced user without the bloat that would be associated with building into the core application.  We are developing similar plans for time tracking (we think this makes more sense as a desktop widget that interacts via the API) and other features that some, but not all, subscribers will use.  I’d be interested to hear feedback from you and your readers on this line of thinking.

Picture of Luc Latulippe Luc Latulippe
2 years, 9 months ago

Seems like the comments field of this thread threatens to become an area for accounting software companies to advertise in. I may put the kibosh to that.

Picture of Jeff Mackey Jeff Mackey
2 years, 8 months ago

Another option would be Billable (http://clickablebliss.com/billable), similar to Billings. I haven’t used it extensively, but it seemed to work rather well during my trial use of it.

Picture of Joe Taylor Joe Taylor
8 months, 1 week ago

Try Studiometry.  My 30 trial has been going very well and it’s been a pretty good fit so far.

Leave a comment:

Remember me

Notify me of follow-up comments by email

 

trackbacks

Journalista - the news weblog of The Comics Journal » Blog Archive » Sept. 21, 2007: Thi

[...] Latulippe goes in search of the accounting software that does it all. He’s still [...]----- [...] a platform by which developers can extend AcuInvoice’s functionality. I wrote about the merits of API-based extensibility at Luc Latulippe’s illustration blog. As an aside, I challenge you to find a more gifted artist [...]----- [...] eye candy for a change and examine something that might actually help struggling artists, shall we? Luc Latulippe offers a look at various small-business accounting software packages, and their suitability in [...]-----

Tracked from: (IP: 63.247.138.218) at 2007 09 21 00:34:35